--tooo funny... smaller is better or back to nature... we always want bigger faster more bang for the buck approach.
--why then do biologist claim/complain that larger hatchery fish unfairly compete with wild fish due to their larger size and feeding habits... someone has is wrong?
--in any case my belief is that we should mimic nature as close as possible.. for our kokanee hatchery (when we were allowed to run it) my proposal was to get the fish back in the stream they came from asap after hatching so they do not become domestic and have to survive the rigours of the stream. the only purpose of the hatchery was to give a boost to initial survival as there are not currently enough returning stream spawning fish. after more than 10 years of hoping for a natural rebound to no avail it is time to try something different. of note shore spawn kokanee in okanagan lake has shown significant increases in the past 10 years since water levels have been managed to accommodate them.. thus one may reasonably speculate that food and lake habitat should not now be the most significant limiting factor for stream spawners.