maxima perfection is their limp clear mono line which was designed for putting on spinning reels to eliminate twisting which you get with stiffer lines. I have used it when it first came out and it was garbage. on and off the reel within the same trip
I bought some P-line flouroclear line for leader line to try out and its very good. its a copolymer line coated with flourocarbon so its invisible. I bought 12lb so i can use it for steely fly swinging, 12lb is the size of 8lb ultragreen. Its very strong so much so that when i try to break off big springs my main line has been the one snapping
got new main line on now though and bumped up to 20lb cause its nicer on the pin
I will be buying some of this line for fishing lakes. probably some 10 or 8lb to use for long leaders before adding my 4lb(flouro) tippet
Where did you buy the damaged line at ?? if its a reputable store they should have no problem exchanging it for you
for example i bought some tippet material at M&Y and it was for sure defective because little fish at Lafarge lake were snapping me off constantly so i took it back and they gave me a new spool (i could have chose another line or store credit also) and the new spool worked just fine.