Ok, since I mod the Buy&Sell I'll answer a few of the rants.
BB: The Buy and Sell is a service to the members of the forum whether they contribute in other sub-forums or not. I've had complaints about the person you speak of but I don't really see it as a problem. He sells gear at reasonable prices and most of it sells quickly, and he posts SOLD when it's gone, therefore removing his thread from the list. It is really just an advantage to other members who are looking for gear.
ScouterJames: I can't do much for you. The Buy&Sell forum is merely a medium for buyers to find sellers and vise-versa. We can't control what happens after that. I've been screwed over a few times too, shipping gear across the province only for the person to deny the package and I have to pay to ship it back.
HOOK: I don't want anyone getting called out publicly because it is only heresy, the seller will rebuttal and the thread will go no where fast.
Fisherforever: I agree, offers should be made via PM or E-Mail. However many times the seller does not have contact info in their profile our in their thread so a 'posted' offer is all someone can make. If the seller wants the offer deleted, they can click the "Report to Moderator" and tell me they want it removed.
DragonSpeed: You are 100% right about not taking offers personally. However, you need to refresh your self on the Buy and Sell Guidlines;
The buy and sell is not an auction board.
If anyone has a problem with something posted in the buy and sell section use the "Report to Moderator" button.