I'm with JC on this .. I guess I have seen the evolution of floats on the Vedder after 50 plus years of fishing it. The first were big, ugly split-side wooden jobs, brown bottom, red top ,that had a nasty habit of falling off your line sometime during the day. To a kid that often used rocks or wheel nuts for weights, losing a float was serious bad news ... and any found float was a gift, as my friend Chris knows.
Next came the ping-pong ball floats crafted by George Friskie, perhaps the most innovative Vedder River angler of the era and arguably to this day. They were a work of art and floated a big chunk of lead and a big gob of bait but were fragile, prone to leaks and a bitch to cast.
We soon started carving dense foam fishing net floats, along with balsa and cedar. After varnishing and painting, these floats were obviously very labour intensive and it hurt big time when the crappy mono lines of the day failed ... it was always the line, never the angler...
and the prized float drifted away.
Finally, foam dink floats came on the scene, first the big fatties an inch wide, 8 inches long and wound on the line with one or two turns...total garbage, imo ... and then big expensive plastic torpedoes with interesting names, that again, are fragile and are often seen abandoned on river banks....
Nah, give me a 6”, ½ “ wide straight thru foam dinker, top painted orange/green anyday. Will float all I want to throw, and as JC says, is easy to retrieve. And cheap