Hmmm, that definition reminds me of creek fishing with fly - just hitting all the pocket water. I didn't realize that was frowned upon.
My interpretation of a Dipper was some thing negative, more towards the snagging side of things where someone may chose to use a large hooked object like a big spoon dipped in a pocket - drift it through the run then rip it out of the water at the end or on any bump.
Thank you - now I know what a Dipper is.
I don't think its frowned upon at all, I think people are starting to knit pick about techniques, if you don't fish their way with set up, spot and at that specific time everyone else is wrong. Your way or the highway mentality. But don't you dare get caught in the same system/body of water cause its super secret and the internets to blame.
Fishing the unfishable spots is kinda my favorite but I do so with my single hand rod. Full Floating w/ a shorter leader because the fly thanks to the current gets down into the strike zone PDQ. All thats needed a good false cast and than lining up the fly directly in front of you, to high up and you'll snag a rock fish or cedar pike
great trophies I grant you! but terrible on the plate! Anyway a quick mend and let it drift right to the beach, if you start to retrieve to soon, you are liking to foul or snag between the boulders, which isn't good that waters fast and ugly, not really safe. Playing tug-a-war is never a good idea.
I tend to do quite well but the only time I have success with that type of fishing is usually when the waters just right, I like it a little on the high side.