Simms warranty on waders is excellent from all I have heard. It would be nice to hear how Redington handles a jacket issue.
To be fair to Simms I should say that both my G3 waders and Guide boots have held up excellent. The waders I've had for 5+ years and I fish fairly often and sometimes bushwack. Have fallen lots on my rear end on rocks, etc. No issues with the waders at all minus some pin hole leaks from prickle bushes or hooks, and that will happen with any brand. Easily repairable with Aquaseal. The boots have also held up unbelievably well. They are on their 3rd refelting now and still looks faily new and fit tight/solid.
The G3 jacket, well, obviously I got a bit of a bad run/lemon. The "bones" of the jacket are fine, just the little fit & finish things like the Velcro pockets and magnets are an issue. Luckily uliwon, the Western Canada Simms Rep, saw this thread and contacted me. He has been straight up and good to deal with. I like honesty! Just tell me what I'm likely to get, unlike Simms USA who led me to believe I'd be taken care of if I mailed them jacket, and we all know how that went. Uliwon was honest in that I'm not going to get a new jacket unless I roll the dice and send my jacket back to Simms (again). I said ain't happening. We worked out a deal where I'm going to get some other stuff that I feel fairly compensates me for my $ spent mailing the jacket, and my time and hassle fixing it myself.