Ok I'll bite... my first post.
Those of you that a re defending the bait ban because it's the law I will applaud. Without the laws there would be no fish. But I have to ask.... how many of you have been at cable pool when the water is high in the fall? Have you seen all the people with the orange and green wool, the 8 foot leaders, the RIP at the end of every cast, the joy on their face when they bring in a black spring jack by the tail? Hey, they caught a fish.
Given a choice those same people would be angling with roe and getting fish to bite, which is what happens at cable pool during the rest of the year when there is no bait ban. But they can't. Not legally. Not without facing a social media back lash.
Ahh the elusive Cap summer steelhead.... in a dozen falls fishing the Cap I have caught only a single steel, and it was on a spinner, and was bleeding like a stuck pig when I released it. I felt bad cause it coulda been the only one that made it past the weir that year. Seriously, I heard that one year the hatchery got only a single summer run, which they released...
But back to the subject at hand. 7/10 people (or so) that catch fish on the Cap in the fall do so by (legal) flossing and outright snagging. Cable, Doctors pool, and Kieth Road are so much of a disgrace that I can't even bring myself to go there during the bait ban. For those of you that only fish Vedder, think Kieth Wilson and Tamahi. And some of them are proud to claim that they have been fishing that way for 30 years (so stfu they say). I asked one guy what colour wool he was using when he caught his spring at dog leg, and he was so embarrassed that he just looked the other way. Sad. Of the remaining 30% that catch fish, I estimate that 10% use lures and 20% use roe.
Sure, there are other pools and I do well enough on spinners not to care.
The Squamish river is bait ban all year. It's not a dammed river, with only a small hatchery for it's size. In this river a bait ban may indeed have a sizable effect. I respect that.
It may be "too easy" to catch fish using roe in the Cap in the fall, but unless you really want sport fishermen to copy the FN style of harvesting I suggest to both DFO and the Squamish band that there should be no bait ban in place on this 100% hatchery river.