"My daughter bought me new Simms pant waders from Freds and out of the box they leaked. They dont have anymore in stock and want to send them back for warranty. 4-6 weeks befored I would get them back..
What a joke, they should stand behind the products they sell and not rely on the manufacturer to deal with it.
Once they get your money they have no interest in fixing the problem.
Have spent 800 bucks in there the last month and will never go back.
Small businesses complain about on line shopping but thats where I will be buying fishing supplies from know on.
Later Fred"
This one is a tough one and a bad situation. I see it as a no win for anyone. This is an obvious manufacturer's defect and this can happen from time to time.
Replacing them would have been ideal, but if they are out of stock, they cannot do that.
They could have repaired them for you with something like Aquaseal or even a patch from the inside, but my guess is that would have long term impacted the warranty and if you had issues down the road, could be problematic.
I also wonder if you bought them on-line and out of the box, they leaked. You would have been in the same place, and probably even more so, so not sure if having an on-line pair would have helped.
To me, it sounds like an apology on Simms behalf would have been all they could have done, and if not really satisfied, offered a refund and another pair of a different brand or model.
Dano