Going to try and reconstruct a post I lost...
so johnny, not to pic a fight with ya, just asking, does this mean you feel it's okay to keep on flossing right now? I hate the fact that i gotta hang up my bb'ing rod right now, as the spring fishing is getting good. However in hopes of seeing NO confrontations with FN and such i can wait till the early sox are through. there's always float fishing the vedder starting july 1st. Setting a prime example right now by not flossing during this early stuart run will show the government, the general public and the first nations fishers that sporties respect the resource. Shame on those that don't recognize this opportunity to do the right thing. Conservation has priority over the dinner plate.
First off, I don't take this question as picking a fight, so no worries.
In regards to whether I would continue to BB, the answer is yes... Now, with that said.. I don't use obscenely long leaders. They have been getting longer and longer every year and in my experience it is unneeded especially when targeting springs. Do I BB the whole day? No. It is strictly to break up the monotony of bar fishing. We switch back and forth throughout the day.
In fishing the last 3 years with a boat(compared to the old days of being stuck on shore *grin*) we have put in a LOT of time on the river and did not hook 1 early sockeye from our boat! Even if we were to hook one with the water temps being cooler than later in the year and the water levels being higher, I would suspect the mortality rate to be very low of a released fish.
Not that one justifies the other BUT: What do you think will catch more early stewart sockeye.. the few sporties(the river isn't very busy this time of year,and out of them a lot are bar fishing) that might be BB'ing or the nets that are out? My guess is that a couple nets will take more fish than the total sum of sporties during this "sensitive" time. As a matter of fact I bet the albion test nets would have as much impact on the run as all sporties combined(only 1 sockeye for them so far this year.. yesterday).
If the river were to be shut down because of BB'ers I would say this:
A. It would be a political move to attempt to place blame on declining stocks on the sport fishermen. Make us look like the bad guys to the general public...
B. It would be the utmost hypocritical act unless there was a total moratorium on ANY fishing in the fraser including FN's along with full enforcement of the moratorium.
I don't see the validity of the arguments that the BB'ers have any affect on these fish, but if I felt I was contributing to their demise I most certainly would reconsider my stance.